Thinking

Home

Thinking

October 18, 2026
•
Dr. Joshua Wilson

The Best Story Usually Feels Ordinary

Habituation. The brain treats repeated experience as background, so what you have lived with for years stops feeling unusual even when someone else would find it meaningful. Your strongest qualities feel ordinary because they are ordinary to you. Discovery is getting far enough outside that familiarity to notice what others already feel.

Someone told me recently that I was surprisingly humble and easy to talk to.

Surprisingly? I laughed.

I appreciated it, although I was also a little confused.

A few days earlier, I had gathered up a pile of Costco Wholesale returns, put them by the door, driven all the way to Costco, and realized I had left the returns sitting in my garage.

I also spend an unreasonable amount of time walking into my kitchen and thinking, “What kind of jerk leaves all these cabinet doors open?”

I live alone.

So when someone seems surprised that I am down to earth, I wonder what kind of life they think I am living over here. I own at least six bottles of eye drops for my dry eyes and still regularly cannot find a single one. I forget why I walked into a room. I apparently believe kitchen cabinets close themselves.

Life provides plenty of reminders that I am just a person, but there is a deeper reason the compliment felt strange. I genuinely do not understand how a title or accomplishment convinces someone they have become a more important class of human being.

Over the last month, I have spoken with CEOs of some of the fastest-growing firms in America and founders building companies that people across the industry are watching closely. I have also talked with an Alabama steelworker and disabled veteran. Good people are everywhere.

There are impressive people in boardrooms. There are impressive people working night shifts, raising families, taking care of aging parents, volunteering at church, and doing work the market will never reward properly. I learned that early.

My dad never built a unicorn startup. He was never on the cover of a business magazine, and he did not make the kind of money our culture uses as evidence that a life mattered. But I watched people leave conversations with him different than when they arrived. I watched him preach messages that changed lives. I watched him sit with people during the worst moments of theirs.

My mom spent thousands of quiet hours investing in me when nobody was watching. A great deal of what people now find impressive about my life began in ordinary rooms with one person giving another person their full attention. That changed how I measure people.

My faith teaches me that human beings have value because they are human beings. Their value does not increase with their income, title, audience, credentials, or proximity to power. Our culture has become very good at measuring status. It remains much worse at recognizing worth.

I have met too many extraordinary people in ordinary places, and too many ordinary people in extraordinary places, to confuse the two. The person living the story has the worst seat in the house

Why do qualified people sound like everyone else?

That compliment stayed with me for another reason. It describes a large part of the work I do.

Many of the people I work with are smart, qualified, experienced, and genuinely good at what they do. They have spent years building judgment, earning trust, making mistakes, serving clients, and becoming the kind of person other people rely on.

Then they sit down to describe themselves, or they have a few precious moments on a stage, and sound exactly like everyone else. They list credentials. They repeat industry language. They reach for words such as experienced, dedicated, trusted, and client-first.

Nothing they say is false. It is simply too familiar to carry much signal.

Part of the problem is habituation. The brain gradually treats repeated experiences as background. What you have lived with for years stops feeling unusual, even when someone else would find it meaningful.

You have watched your own life from inside it.

The hard season you survived became something that happened a long time ago. The unusual way you think became “just how I think.” The small habit that makes clients trust you became “just part of the job.”

Your strongest qualities often feel ordinary because they are ordinary to you.

What does expert discovery actually mean?

That is why expert discovery matters. Far, far beyond the template.

Discovery does not mean inventing a heroic origin story or turning every childhood memory into a brand lesson. It means getting far enough outside your own familiarity to notice what other people can already feel.

It means finding the experiences, beliefs, tensions, language, and small human details that make you emotionally legible.

One of my clients admitted that she questioned this part of the process at first.

“When we went through the stories in the beginning, part of me wondered whether it could be a waste of time. I didn’t understand why those things mattered.

The funny thing is, those stories did not necessarily show up directly in the work we created later. But doing that digging changed how I saw them. I started bringing them up naturally in the right moments because I understood they were an underlying current in how I connect with people and meet them where they are.

At first, I didn’t realize that was the work. We weren’t simply telling the story. The discovery changed how I approached those moments and helped me recognize the parts people could relate to.

It made me more human. It made me more comfortable sharing. People could think, ‘Oh, you’re like me. I get you. Let’s do this.’

It puts people at ease. It takes away some of the buttoned-up feeling that can come across as cold, unapproachable, fake, or unrealistic, and replaces it with something people can connect to.”

That is the part people frequently misunderstand.

Discovery can feel inefficient because the outcome does not always look like a neatly packaged story placed on an About page.

Sometimes the story becomes content. Sometimes it becomes language. Sometimes it changes which details you notice in a conversation, which parts of yourself you are comfortable sharing, or how you explain an idea when someone needs to feel understood. It always strengthens the brand.

The story may never appear word for word. The person who went through the discovery appears everywhere.

What is the difference between remarkable and resonant?

Remarkability and resonance are different jobs. Many branding conversations obsess over being remarkable. Remarkability earns attention. It gives someone a reason to stop, look, or remember. That's very important.

Yet resonance goes deeper. It creates recognition. Recognition is the feeling of encountering another person and thinking, “This person understands something about me,” or, “This is someone I could trust.”

That feeling rarely comes from the largest or most polished story.

It can come from a graduation speech someone discovers online. It can come from the way a founder talks about the people using the product. It can come from the fact that someone speaks to a steelworker with the same interest and respect they give a CEO.

It can even come from Costco returns sitting in a garage and a kitchen full of open cabinet doors. The details are small. The worldview they signal is not.

My cabinet story says something about self-awareness. My reaction to titles says something about dignity. My parents’ stories explain why I value quiet forms of influence that never show up on a résumé.

Those details help someone experience me as a person before they evaluate me as a professional. That is signal. AI can scale a discovered signal. But without that, it's just scaling sameness.

What does AI change about brand storytelling?

We now have tools that can produce more content, in more formats, for more channels, faster than any individual or firm could have imagined a few years ago. That capacity is useful, but it also creates a serious problem. Everyone else has it too.

Welcome to the age of content inflation, where more and better content buys less and less attention.

As the cost of producing competent language falls, people are being flooded with more information written in the same polished, reasonable, professionally acceptable voice.

More people can get a message into the market. That lowers the value of most messages, but it raises the value of having something worth hearing.

AI can help articulate a thought. It can organize ideas, sharpen language, generate variations, and adapt a message across formats.

AI becomes dangerous when we ask a distribution tool to perform discovery.

Give it a thin description of a financial advisor or founder and ask it to make that person stand out. A few minutes later, it will return a polished version of what the market already expects.

One prompt later, you’ve got Alex Hormozi’s Value Equation bolted onto Donald Miller's StoryBrand, stuffed inside Simon Sinek’s Golden Circle, and dusted with enough dopamine, cortisol, and “subconscious trust” language to make the whole thing sound scientific.

Experienced. Passionate. Trusted. Different.

The language is polished. The person has disappeared.

AI can scale a discovered signal. Before discovery, it mostly scales sameness.

That distinction will become more important as the volume of content rises. When everyone can publish, publishing becomes less valuable. When everyone can sound competent, competence becomes harder to feel.

The next level is connection.

What sits above and below marketing?

The layers around marketing

I think about growth through three connected layers.

Marketing sits in the middle. It carries a message into the market through content, campaigns, media, events, referrals, and repetition. Marketing creates distribution and attention. It is useful and necessary.

The signal layer sits above marketing.

The signal is the source material. It includes the person’s lived experience, worldview, language, motives, distinctions, stories, proof, and personality. It gives marketing something worth carrying.

When the source signal is generic, more reach simply gives sameness a larger audience.

The pressure layer sits below marketing.

Pressure concerns what happens inside another person when the message reaches them. It includes the emotional weight of the problem, the uncertainty that needs to be reduced, the identity being affirmed, the trust cues being received, and the experience someone needs before taking the next step.

Signal defines what you are sending. Pressure determines what the message does inside the person receiving it.

A strong signal with weak pressure can get noticed and forgotten. Strong pressure attached to a weak or manufactured signal can feel manipulative.

Marketing can distribute either one. It cannot repair them.

My work lives above marketing and below it.

Above marketing, I help people discover the signal that has been buried under credentials, professional language, and years of familiarity.

Below marketing, I help shape the emotional experience so the signal reaches the right person in the right way. That includes understanding what earns attention, what creates connection, what reduces uncertainty, and what helps someone feel the truth of the message before they begin calculating the details.

Then marketing carries it through the middle.

The best people often have the hardest time seeing themselves. A lot of the best people do not know how to stand out.

They assume standing out requires self-promotion, exaggeration, louder claims, or some giant story that proves they are extraordinary. Those options feel uncomfortable, so they retreat into credentials and safe professional language.

They become easier to verify and harder to feel.

Credentials matter because they reduce uncertainty. They tell us someone has met a standard. But a standard is shared by everyone else who met it.

Connection comes from what the standard cannot explain.

It comes from why you chose the work. It comes from what you notice that other people miss. It comes from the experiences that shaped how you treat people, make decisions, handle pressure, and define success. Often, it comes from details you almost left out because they did not seem impressive enough.

That is the most rewarding part of my work.

I get to help good people see what familiarity has hidden from them. Then we give those qualities language and structure so other people can experience the depth that was already there. It makes the person more legible without turning them into a performance.

Sometimes the signal is a graduation speech. Sometimes it is a father whose conversations changed people. Sometimes it is treating an Alabama steelworker and a silicon-valley CEO as equally worth your attention.

And sometimes it is a garage full of Costco returns and a kitchen full of open cabinet doors. Small details can carry an entire worldview.

Discovery finds them. Strategy gives them structure. Marketing gives them reach. The experience proves they were true.

The best story is usually already happening. Most people are simply too close to see it.

Frequently asked questions

Why does my own story feel boring even when others find it interesting?

Habituation. The brain treats anything repeated as background noise, so the details you have lived with for years stop registering as unusual to you, even when they're exactly what makes someone else trust you.

How do you find your brand story if you don't think you have one?

Not by inventing a heroic origin story. Discovery means getting far enough outside your own familiarity to notice what other people can already feel about you: the small, specific details you'd normally leave out because they don't seem impressive enough.